Outdated Website Test: 10 Checks and What to Tell the Owner
A 10-point test for an outdated website, with a sourced threshold and a time for each check, and the words to use with the owner.
Thijs Veer, Founder
13 min read
An outdated website is one that fails today's public standards, whatever its age. You can test any site in about 8 minutes with 10 checks, one for each area Twip AI scores. Five of the checks have a threshold from a named public source, such as Google's 2.5-second mark for loading. By our own rule of thumb, a site that fails 3 or more is worth a letter to its owner.
This guide gives the test, a way to judge how outdated a site is and the words to use with the owner. Most sections link to a guide that goes deeper.
How do you tell if a website is outdated?
Run the 10 checks in the table and count the fails. Most need only your phone, a desktop browser and Google's free PageSpeed Insights. A check fails when the site misses the mark in the Fails when column.
| # | Domain | The check | Fails when | Where the mark comes from | Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Design | Footer year and the newest dated post | Both are 2 or more years old | Our rule of thumb | 30 s |
| 2 | Speed | PageSpeed Insights, mobile tab | LCP over 2.5 s or CLS over 0.1 | web.dev | 60 s |
| 3 | Mobile | Open the site on your phone | You have to pinch to read, or tap targets are under 24 by 24 CSS pixels | WCAG 2.2 | 45 s |
| 4 | Security | Look at the address bar in Chrome | Chrome shows "Not secure" | Google Chrome Help | 15 s |
| 5 | SEO | Search the site's name, then its service and town | Page titles read "Home" or repeat, or the business is missing for its own service | Our rule of thumb | 60 s |
| 6 | Accessibility | Contrast checker on the body text | Contrast under 4.5 to 1 | W3C, WCAG 2.1 | 60 s |
| 7 | Content | Read the homepage and the services page | Old offers, past events, staff who left, old prices | Our rule of thumb | 45 s |
| 8 | Conversion | First screen on a phone, then send the form | No way to call, book or ask for a quote on that screen, or the form fails | Our rule of thumb | 60 s |
| 9 | Trust | Look for reviews, real photos, an address and a license | None of the four appear | Our rule of thumb | 30 s |
| 10 | Technology | View the page source, or a tool such as Wappalyzer | The CMS or server software is a version its maker no longer supports | The maker's own release list | 75 s |
The times are our estimates. They add up to 480 seconds, or 8 minutes a site. Five marks come from public sources. The other five are ours, and the table says so.
For what each failure looks like on a local business site, see our bad website examples.
What does each check look for, and what do you tell the owner?
Each check below gives the mark, how to run it and one line you could say to the owner. Every line to an owner is a made-up example. Replace it with what you found.
1. Design. Is the site visibly old?
Read the copyright year in the footer and the date of the newest news or blog post. A footer year that is current proves little, because many sites print the year with a script. An old year proves that nobody has touched the footer since.
Tell the owner. "Your footer still says 2019, and the newest post on the site is from the same spring."
2. Speed. Does the main content show within 2.5 seconds?
Google counts a page as good when Largest Contentful Paint is 2.5 seconds or less, Interaction to Next Paint is 200 milliseconds or less and Cumulative Layout Shift is 0.1 or less, at the 75th percentile of page loads (web.dev). Paste the address into PageSpeed Insights and read the mobile tab. Many small local sites have too little traffic for field data, so you will often see only the lab test. LCP and CLS still show there.
Tell the owner. "On a phone, your homepage took 6 seconds to show its main content. Google's mark for a good page is 2.5."
3. Mobile. Does it work on a phone?
Google uses the mobile version of a site's content for indexing and ranking (Google Search Central). So the phone view is the site Google judges. Open it on your own phone. Text you must pinch to read fails. So do buttons smaller than 24 by 24 CSS pixels, the Level AA minimum in WCAG 2.2. The rule lists five exceptions, links inside a sentence among them.
Tell the owner. "On my phone, the menu covers your phone number and I couldn't close it."
4. Security. Does the browser call it "Not secure"?
Chrome marks a page "Not secure" when it does not use a private connection, and Google's help page says the owner must secure the site with HTTPS to fix it (Google Chrome Help). Open the contact page as well as the homepage. Some sites cover the homepage and forget the form.
Tell the owner. "Chrome shows 'Not secure' on your contact page, right where people type their phone number."
5. SEO. Can search read it?
Search the business name and read the result. A title that says "Home" means the basics were never set. Then search the main service and the town without the name. If competitors appear and the business does not, write that down.
Tell the owner. "When I search 'water heater repair Tulsa', three competitors show up and you don't."
6. Accessibility. Can everyone read the text?
WCAG 2.1 asks for a contrast ratio of at least 4.5 to 1 for normal text and 3 to 1 for large text, at Level AA (W3C). Check the body text with a contrast checker such as the one from WebAIM, or run the accessibility audit in Chrome's Lighthouse. Expect fails. WebAIM's February 2026 scan of the top one million home pages found low contrast text on 83.9% of them (WebAIM).
Tell the owner. "Your gray body text on white is hard to read on a phone in daylight, and it falls short of the contrast level the accessibility standard sets."
7. Content. Is it still true?
Read the homepage and the services page as a customer would. Look for a past event, a service the business dropped, a team member who left or prices from years ago. One stale fact makes a visitor doubt the rest.
Tell the owner. "Your homepage still invites people to the open day on May 12, 2022."
8. Conversion. Can a ready buyer act on the first screen?
Open the site on your phone and look at the first screen only. A visitor should see a way to call, book or ask for a quote without scrolling. Then send the contact form with your own details and see whether it confirms.
Tell the owner. "I sent your quote form twice and got an error page both times."
9. Trust. Is there proof?
Look for four things. Reviews, real photos of the team or the work, a street address and any license or membership the trade expects. A site with none of the four could belong to anyone.
Tell the owner. "You have 140 five-star reviews on Google and none of them appear on your site."
10. Technology. Is the software still supported?
Right-click the page and choose View page source. Search the source for "generator" and for "ver=", which often reveal the CMS and its version. A browser extension such as Wappalyzer can show the same. Then compare each version with its maker's own list of supported releases. A version the maker no longer supports gets no security fixes.
Tell the owner. "Your site runs on a version of its software that no longer gets security fixes."
Keep this line plain. Many owners have never heard the word CMS. A security fix needs no explaining.
How outdated is the website?
Count the fails. The number tells you what to sell. These bands are our own rule of thumb, built on the 10 checks.
- 0 to 2 fails. Dated in places. Sell a short fix list or a care plan. A redesign would be hard to justify.
- 3 to 5 fails. Outdated. A redesign makes sense, above all when the fails include speed, mobile, security or conversion, because those touch every visitor.
- 6 or more fails. Past repair. Quote a rebuild. Our guide to website redesign cost shows how to price it.
At scale, Twip AI does the scoring. It scores every website in a search out of 100 across the same 10 domains. Lower means a weaker website, and sites that score below 40 form the shortlist. Our bands are a count of fails by hand. They do not convert into a Twip score.
How long does the test take across a whole list?
At 8 minutes a site, the hand test works for a short list and breaks down on a long one. Here is the arithmetic.
- 50 sites at 8 minutes is 400 minutes, or 6 hours 40 minutes.
- 500 sites is 4,000 minutes, or about 67 hours.
- Our October 2026 study, linked in the next section, looked back at an earlier campaign that emailed 1,382 Dutch companies. Reviewing those sites by hand would have taken about 184 hours, at about 8 minutes a site. Nobody did it.
So check by hand when you work one trade in one town. Past about 50 sites, a tool has to do the first pass. That is what Twip's AI analysis is for. For a full review of one site after the first pass, use a website audit and our website audit checklist.
Why is an outdated website a better lead?
Owners of weak sites replied more often in our own test. We scored 20,000 Dutch company websites and emailed 3 groups, 3,570 emails in all (the full study).
| Group | Who got the email | Positive replies |
|---|---|---|
| A | A random sample from the 80% of sites with fewer problems | 0.50% |
| B | The 20% of sites with the most problems, generic email | 1.60% |
| C | The same 20%, email names the problem | 2.35% |
Picking the weakest sites made a business about 3.2 times more likely to reply positively. Naming the problem did better again, but the gap between B and C was not statistically significant (p = 0.238).
Know the limits before you quote it. The study covered Dutch companies. It tested email only. It left out businesses with no website. It says nothing about letters or LinkedIn.
There is a plain reason it fits. An owner with an outdated website has bought a website before and knows it matters. You are selling an upgrade. Our guide to businesses that need websites covers the same point from the search side.
How do you tell the owner their website is outdated?
Never use the word "outdated". Put your strongest finding in the first line, say what it costs a customer, say what you would change and offer the rest. Four moves, in a few short sentences.
The first line decides whether the rest gets read. Pick it by two rules.
- The owner can check it in under a minute, on their own phone, with no tool. "Not secure", a broken form and a menu that covers the phone number all pass. A Core Web Vitals score does not, so it goes second.
- It costs a customer something today. A footer year is easy to check, and it costs nothing. Use it late or never.
Here is a made-up letter built that way, for a made-up plumber at ridgelineplumbing.example.
Your quote form at ridgelineplumbing.example sits under a "Not secure" label in Chrome, right where people type their phone number.
Some of them will stop there and call the next plumber. On my phone, the homepage also took about 6 seconds to show its main content, and Google's mark for a good page is 2.5.
Both are fixable in one redesign. I found 4 more points like these and put them on one page. If you want it, call me at 555-0142.
This is the letter-first view. Your Outbound Machine posts the letter so it arrives on day 1. Emails follow on days 4, 7 and 11, and LinkedIn on days 15 and 19, all working days. Twip's findings become the opening line of each letter and email. The sequence stops for a business the moment it replies.
You choose how much to review. You can read every letter before it goes, check a sample such as the first 100, or let your Outbound Machine send without review. Our guide explains why the letter goes first, and how to sell websites to local businesses covers the call that follows.
What are the benefits of website redesign for the owner?
Each failed check, once fixed, is a benefit the owner can see. That makes the benefits of website redesign easy to list for one site. Write them from the fails you found, and promise no traffic or sales figure.
| Failed check | What the owner gets once the check passes |
|---|---|
| Security | The "Not secure" label disappears from every page |
| Speed | The main content shows within Google's 2.5-second mark |
| Mobile | The phone view, the one Google indexes, works |
| Accessibility | Body text meets the 4.5 to 1 contrast level |
| Conversion | A ready buyer can call or book from the first screen |
| Content and trust | Visitors see the business as it is today, with its reviews |
| Technology | The software gets security fixes again |
The strongest reasons to redesign a website are those fails, because the owner can check each one. Two more reasons come from the business. It changed its services or its area, or it changed its name or look. Our website redesign checklist takes the project from there, redirects included.
How often should you redesign your website?
Redesign when the test shows 3 or more fails, or when the business itself changes. Run the 10 checks once a year to know where you stand.
Agency blogs often name a fixed span of years. The test is a better guide. A site built 2 years ago can fail today, because the marks move. WCAG 2.2 added a Level AA minimum target size of 24 by 24 CSS pixels. Google now indexes the mobile version of a site. A site built well 6 years ago can also pass all 10 checks and need only fixes.
For an agency, the yearly test doubles as a reason to call. Each fail is a line item, and a care plan that reruns the test shows the client each new fail as it appears.
Questions
How can I tell if my website is outdated?
Open it on your phone and look at the address bar, the first screen and the footer. A "Not secure" label, a menu that covers the phone number or a footer year from years ago each point to an outdated website. For a fuller answer, run all 10 checks in this guide. It takes about 8 minutes.
What makes a website look outdated?
Old dates, stale offers, stock photos and a layout that was built for a desktop screen. Each makes a visitor wonder whether the business is still trading. Looks matter less than whether the site works, so check speed, mobile and the form too.
Can an outdated website hurt SEO?
Yes, when it fails on a phone. Google uses the mobile version of a site's content for indexing and ranking, so a site that breaks on a phone is what Google reads. Page titles that all say "Home" also give search nothing to work with.
Is it better to update or redesign an outdated website?
Count the fails. With 0 to 2, update the parts that fail. With 3 to 5, we would quote a redesign, because fixing problems one at a time in old software adds up. With 6 or more, a rebuild is the honest quote.
How do you tell a client their website is outdated without offending them?
Report one fact they can check, such as an error on their quote form, and say what it costs their customers. Skip words like "outdated" or "old". Offer the rest of your findings only if they ask.
Does a current copyright year mean the site is up to date?
No. Many sites print the current year with a script, so it updates with no one touching the site. An old year is a useful sign, and a current one proves little.
Next step. Twip AI scores every website in a search across the same 10 domains, and its findings become the opening line of each letter and email. See AI Analysis.

