How to Sell SEO: The Full Sale From Letter to Package

The whole SEO sale on paper, from a first letter built on the prospect's own site to a signed package.

Thijs Veer, Founder

12 min read

Contents

To sell SEO to a local business, open with findings from the owner's own website that they can check in a minute. Promise no ranking. Follow up on a fixed schedule, then run a short discovery call and offer three packages. This guide shows how to sell SEO with every piece written out for one made-up roofer.

Each part of how to sell SEO services is written out below. You get the letter, the emails, the LinkedIn notes, the call and the packages, in the order they happen.

What does the whole SEO sale look like on paper?

The sale is eight pieces in a fixed order. Six of them are outreach steps over 19 working days. The last two are a call and a proposal.

#WhenChannelWhat it saysWhat it is for
1Day 1Posted letterThree findings from their site, a short askGet read by the owner
2Day 4EmailThe finding that costs them the mostMake replying easy
3Day 7EmailA second finding, with Google's own numberAdd proof
4Day 11EmailAn offer to send a one-page summaryLower the ask
5Day 15LinkedInA connection request with a short messagePut a face to the name
6Day 19LinkedInA second message once they acceptLast touch
7After a replyCallFive questions, no slidesLearn what one customer is worth
8Within 2 days of the callProposalTheir findings, then three packagesGet a signature

Day 1 is the day the letter arrives, and the days are working days. The schedule stops for a business the moment it replies. In Leadodo, your Outbound Machine runs steps 1 to 6 on this schedule.

Who should you sell SEO to?

Sell SEO to businesses that customers search for, where one new customer pays for months of work, and whose site shows gaps the owner can see. A roofer, a dentist or a law firm usually fits. A business that wins all its work by referral often does not.

Three questions qualify a prospect before you write a word.

  1. Do people search for what it sells, in its area? Type the service and the town into Google. If competitors show up with ads and map listings, the demand is there.
  2. Is one customer worth enough? One roof replacement or one new legal client covers a lot of monthly SEO work. One haircut does not.
  3. Can someone there approve changes to the site? If the nephew who built it in 2017 holds the only login, find out before the call.

Then sort by how weak the site is. Weak SEO on a sound site is a pure SEO sale. A site that is weak everywhere needs a rebuild first, and our guide to SEO leads explains how to tell the two apart.

Weak sites are also where replies come from. In the test of 3,570 cold emails to Dutch companies that we published in October 2026, the businesses with the weakest 20% of websites were about 3.2 times more likely to reply positively than a random sample of the rest. Emails that named the problem got 2.35% positive replies, against 1.60% for a generic email to the same weak sites. That difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.238). The test covered email only and says nothing about letters or LinkedIn. The full method is in our write-up of the test.

Twip AI, the AI inside Leadodo, scores every website in a search out of 100 across 10 domains, and SEO is one of them. Lower means a weaker website and a better lead. Sites below 40 form the shortlist. See how Twip scores a site.

What goes in the first letter?

The first letter names three things you found on the owner's site, each one checkable in a minute, and asks for 20 minutes. It promises no ranking. It is signed by a person, with a phone number.

An SEO pitch is the case you make to an owner for paying you to improve how their business shows up in search. The letter is the first page of that case. It should read like a note from someone who looked, because you did.

Google's page for owners who are hiring an SEO says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central). Your letter should be the one in the pile that never claims otherwise.

Here is the letter for one made-up business. Copperline Roofing, the town of Alder Falls, Ray, Maya and Brightmark Search do not exist. The findings are examples too. Check every finding on the real site before you send.

Dear Ray,

I searched "roof repair Alder Falls" on my phone last week. Three roofers came up on the map. Copperline was not one of them, though you have more Google reviews than two of the three.

I looked at copperlineroofing.example to see why. Three things stood out.

  1. Every service sits on one page. Someone searching "metal roof installation Alder Falls" finds a competitor's page for exactly that, and Google has no page of yours to show.
  2. On a phone, your home page took 5.8 seconds to show its main content. Google's own mark for a good page is 2.5 seconds.
  3. Your Google Business Profile says you close at 5 pm. Your website says 6 pm.

You can check each of these yourself in about a minute. I would fix the first one first.

If you want to see what that looks like, I can walk you through it in 20 minutes, by phone or at your office. I will not promise you a ranking, because nobody honestly can.

Maya Lindqvist
Brightmark Search
555-0142

Why a letter goes first is its own topic, and our guide to direct mail for agencies covers it. For the craft of the page itself, see how to write a sales letter.

In Leadodo, Twip's findings become the opening line of each letter and email. You choose how much to review. You can read every letter before it goes, review a sample such as the first 100, or let your Outbound Machine send without review.

What do the emails and LinkedIn messages say?

Each follow-up adds one new finding or one smaller ask. None of them repeats the whole letter. They stop the moment the owner replies.

Here is the day 4 email in full, for the same made-up business.

Subject. Copperline's service pages

Hi Ray,

My letter about copperlineroofing.example should have reached you on Monday. In case it went into the pile, here is the short version.

Search "metal roof installation Alder Falls" and three competitors have a page for that job. Copperline has none, so Google has nothing of yours to show for it. One page per service is the first thing I would change.

Worth 20 minutes this week?

Maya

The rest of the schedule follows the same pattern.

  1. Day 7, email. The speed finding, with Google's mark of 2.5 seconds for a good page (web.dev) and the number you measured.
  2. Day 11, email. "Should I send you a one-page summary instead?" A yes here is a reply, and the schedule stops.
  3. Day 15, LinkedIn. A connection request with one line. "I wrote to you about Copperline's website. Happy to connect either way."
  4. Day 19, LinkedIn. A second message once Ray has accepted. One finding, one question, no attachment.

Every email carries a valid postal address and a plain way to opt out. Those are two of the eight requirements in the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide, and the law has no exception for business email. This is not legal advice.

For more wording, our cold email follow-up templates cover every kind of no-reply.

What can the owner check for free with Google's own tools?

The owner can confirm most SEO findings in a few minutes with Google Search, PageSpeed Insights and their own Business Profile. Invite them to. A pitch the owner can verify alone carries more weight than one they have to take on trust.

Put these five checks in the letter, the proposal or both.

  1. Search the service and the town on a phone. Look at the map results and the first page. Is the business there?
  2. Search "site:" followed by the domain. Count the pages Google shows and read their titles. Ten pages all titled "Home" is a finding.
  3. Open the site on a phone. Google "uses the mobile version of a site's content, crawled with the smartphone agent, for indexing and ranking" (Google Search Central). What the owner sees on a phone is what Google ranks.
  4. Run the home page through PageSpeed Insights. Read Largest Contentful Paint for mobile. Good is 2.5 seconds or less, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads (web.dev).
  5. Open the Google Business Profile. Compare its hours, phone number and website link with the site.

None of the five needs a paid tool or a login the owner lacks. That matters when you sell local SEO. An owner with no time for a 20-page report can still run all five checks from a phone.

How do you run the discovery call?

Ask five questions, take notes and show nothing on screen until you know what one customer is worth. The call is for learning. The proposal does the selling.

  1. What is one new job worth to you, on average?
  2. Which jobs do you want more of, and which do you turn down?
  3. Who can change the website, and how long does a change take?
  4. Have you paid for SEO before? What happened?
  5. How do you know today where a new customer came from?

Our list of discovery call questions goes deeper on each.

Expect one question back. Google suggests that owners ask an SEO "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?" (Google Search Central). Answer with what you will change in month 1, what you will measure and when you will report it. Never with a position.

Other pushback follows a pattern too. "We tried SEO and nothing happened" and "Can you get us to page one?" both have honest answers, and our guide to sales objections lists them.

How do you package SEO in three tiers?

Offer three packages, each one a step up in scope from the last. Build each from the findings, so the owner can see which problem every line fixes.

PackageWhat it coversBuilt from
1. Fix the baseOne-off. One page per service, unique titles, Business Profile corrected, Google Search Console set up, the slowest mobile page fixedThe three findings in the letter
2. Grow locallyPackage 1, then monthly. New pages for the jobs the owner wants more of, a review request routine and a monthly reportAnswers to call questions 1 and 2
3. Lead the areaPackage 2, plus pages for each nearby town served and outreach for local links and mentionsCompetitors found in check 1

Price each package from your own hours and costs, and write the middle one as the one you recommend. Our guide to agency pricing models shows how to set a retainer. If you plan to deliver some of the work through a partner, read white label SEO first. Google reminds owners that "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (Google Search Central), and the same goes for an agency and its subcontractors.

The proposal follows the same order as the sale. Page 1 repeats the findings from the letter. Page 2 lists the three packages. Page 3 says what you will report each month and when the owner can leave. Send it within 2 days of the call, while the findings are fresh.

What does the first touch cost?

The letter is the only step in the sequence that carries postage. In Leadodo, a US letter costs about 86 cents for one page in black and white, sent First Class, with printing, postage and the envelope included.

Here is the arithmetic for one trade in one metro.

  1. Search one trade in one area, for example roofers around a mid-sized city.
  2. Keep the sites that score below 40. Say that leaves 200 businesses. The 200 is a made-up count for this example.
  3. 200 letters at about 86 cents each comes to about $172.
  4. The emails and LinkedIn messages that follow add no postage.

How many of the 200 reply depends on the trade, the town and the letter. We have no reply rate for letters or LinkedIn that we can publish, so this guide gives none. Track your own replies per 100 letters and adjust from there.

For the system around this, from niche to pipeline, see our pillar on agency lead generation.

Questions

How do I pitch SEO to a small business?

Lead with one or two findings from their own site that they can check in a minute, such as a missing service page or a slow mobile load. Say what you would change first. Ask for 20 minutes. Leave rankings, jargon and your agency's history out of the first message.

Can you guarantee rankings when you sell SEO?

No. Google tells owners that "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central). Promise the work instead. Name what you will change, what you will measure and when you will report.

How to sell local SEO to an owner who was burned before?

Ask what the last agency did and what they reported. Then show findings the owner can confirm alone with Google Search and their Business Profile. A small first package with a clear list of fixes is easier to say yes to than a 12-month retainer.

Do you need to be an SEO expert to sell SEO services?

You need to understand every finding you put in a letter and every line in your packages. Delivery can be shared with a partner, as long as you check their work. The owner holds you responsible for the work either way.

Should the first message include a free SEO audit?

Send three findings, and keep the full audit for the call or the proposal. A long report from a stranger tends to go unread. The findings are the hook. The audit is part of what you sell.

How many SEO packages should you offer?

Three. Each one adds scope to the one before. The first fixes the base, the second grows the site each month and the third covers the whole area the business serves.


Next step. See how your Outbound Machine sends the letter, the three emails and the two LinkedIn steps on schedule. See the Outbound Machine.

Keep reading

All posts

Your next client is already in the database.

Get started, or book a demo first.